Conservation Via Valuation

When we consider that cat sightings play an important role in why our guests come to Chan Chich Lodge, this type of valuation is something we can get behind whole heartedly. Thanks again to the Anthropocene for this interesting piece of daily science. And thanks again to for their role in the research.

The lesson of the $300,000 bobcat

What is a bobcat worth? There’s a few ways of thinking about that question. One answer, of course, is that a bobcat’s value is intrinsic, their lives not something to signify with a price tag. Fair enough. But for the sake of discussion, and because there’s already a market for their hides, let’s run the math: in the state of Wyoming, a bobcat is worth roughly $300 dead and up to $308,000 alive. And in that vast difference is a tension — some would call it a flaw — in the way these marvelous cats, and many other species too, are presently managed in North America.

The calculations come from a study recently published in the journal Biodiversity and Conservation. Led by Mark Elbroch, a biologist with Panthera, the wild cat conservation organization, and also featuring researchers from wildlife advocacy group Wyoming Untrapped, the researchers totaled the revenues generated in 2015-2016 from selling trapping licenses in that state — $152,000 — and divided them by 1,160 bobcats killed, then added the average sale value of pelts. The final per-bobcat value came to $315.17.

Then Elbroch’s team turned to the example of a bobcat living along the Madison River in Yellowstone National Park, where his predilection for hunting waterfowl made him popular among wildlife lovers. They surveyed 46 photographers who traveled to Wyoming in winter 2015-2016 and the outfitters who guided them. Between outfitters’ fees, money spent on food, lodging and travel, and revenues from selling pictures, the bobcat generated $308,105, or a thousand-fold increase from his worth as a source of fur alone.

The researchers don’t argue that every living bobcat in Wyoming is worth more than $300,000.

Clearly that’s not the case — there’s a limit to how many people want to photograph the animals, demand for high-end bobcat pictures isn’t infinite — but it’s also not the point. Rather, Elbroch’s team wanted to demonstrate that bobcats can be worth far more than their hides and the cost of a trapping license. Hunting and trapping, however, remains the ethos by which these cats are managed in Wyoming and elsewhere.

Thirty-nine U.S. states and eight Canadian provinces allow bobcats to be hunted or trapped. Only 13 states and four provinces have any limits on the number killed. It’s a recipe for trouble, reminiscent of 19th- and early-20th century wildlife slaughters that prompted the system of regulated consumption that now guides the management of most game species. And trouble there is: in 2013, the surging fashionability of fur in Russia and China drove the price of bobcat pelts to a peak of more than $1,000, which led to a spike in trapping and a decline in the cats’ populations.

The last bit is difficult to empiricize, though, because bobcats are notoriously difficult to count and trapping so poorly monitored. The researchers recommend that all states and provinces require better reporting and permits for selling hides; set ecologically sound limits on the number killed; and manage bobcats as game species. That’s at least a first step towards making bobcat trapping sustainable. Not every bobcat will generate so much money as the one from Madison River, but there are still considerable tourism opportunities jeopardized by mismanagement. “Potential exists everywhere,” says Elbroch.

Read the entire article here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s